- cross-posted to:
- palestyna@szmer.info
- world@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- palestyna@szmer.info
- world@lemmy.world
You must log in or register to comment.
Reminds me of a Saturday Night Live joke from years ago…
“Russia announced today that 31 people died from the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant, but they would like to remind everyone that, while tragic, it’s still a far cry from the 400 who died during the Stalinist Purges.”
Yeah it is really funny when they have to make human bodypart puzzles to find out how many people died and also analyze the charred remains of people that were bound together and then burned so they couldn’t say the if it was just one dead person or more.
My understanding was that the burnt bodies were from the IDF shelling of buildings with militants and hostages in them. Did you have additional evidence I didn’t catch?
Those articles partly talk about the burn victims. The Snopes article is primarily about beheaded infants though.
https://www.snopes.com/news/2023/10/12/40-israeli-babies-beheaded-by-hamas/
Right. So we’re not going on much here.
I don’t know if you’re referring to Gaza or Israel on October 7th, but here’s a press conference about the burned bodies.
Yeah, I saw it.
I keep reading descriptions of these scenes on social media, but none with links to corroborated reports from reputable outlets. I am reluctant to believe these stories since the ‘40 beheaded babies’ claim was debunked. Do you have a link to a good report, preferably without a pay wall?
Here’s a PBS video https://youtu.be/jRccpmfQrEE?si=lv3pfejLk1n9E7sg
It’s probably a lot more than 40 in various states of intentional or indirect dismemberment, burnings, decapitations, or complete disintegration to the point where only teeth remain.
There are also various archives with have images and videos corroborated by this report and other news outlets, like Haaretz, NYT, the Guardian, and others.
EDIT: Ah this was about Palestinian burned bodies not Israeli, my apologies.
Thanks. The video is an interview with Greame Wood, and I was able to find his article in the Atlantic describing the footage collected and presented by the IDF, dated October 23. It’s certainly horrifying. He specifically remarks that the presentation featured no signs of rape, apparently in reference to earlier, uncorroborated claims. There’s also no mention of victims being tied together and then deliberately set on fire, which is the unsourced allegation I have seen going around lately. Frustratingly, he doesn’t say one way or the other whether the footage shows that any of the attackers were “looking for kids to kill them” as implied by the IDF presenter.
Ah this was about Palestinian burned bodies not Israeli, my apologies.
What did you mean by that? It’s been suggested there’s been some difficulty figuring which remains belong to the attackers versus the victims, which seems plausible, but I haven’t seen any sources confirming that that’s the situation.
The allegation of victims tied together and set on fire is absolutely true. I saw the images, and here is an article with it.
This article is corroborated by The Guardian, who was at the same press conference, but chose not to post that picture, but a couple other ones.
I saw another image of this mother and child as seen at the scene of the crime too in an archive curated by first responders at the scene.
Many, many of the victims were burned alive.
Edit: Haaretz was probably at the press conference too.
I’m not so sure about that The Media Line link. I searched The Guardian and only only came up with this article, which describes an adult and child having died in a fire while holding each other with no mention of being restrained with steel wire:
Kugel showed journalists an image of one burned and almost unidentifiable collection of bones collected from a saferoom in one kibbutz, then a scan of those remains.
In it, two spines and two sets of ribs were visible, one smaller than the other, which he said told a painful story of their deaths. “This is an adult with a child. They are sitting together and hugging,” Kugel said.
The Media Line article interviews the same Dr. Chen Kugel, head of Israel’s National Center for Forensic Medicine, but omits his above description and does not attribute the steel wire claim to any sources. It’s also vague about whether the victims were directly set on fire or whether they died in burning buildings. In comparison, the Guardian article clearly states as follows:
With some less damaged bodies found in burned buildings, soot in the trachea showed that victims were alive when a fire was set and probably died of smoke inhalation, Kugel said. He wants families to know that victims would have died from smoke inhalation before flames reached their bodies.
The Media Line article even ends by quoting an obvious lie that “No one who was alive and encountered them [the Gazan attackers] remained alive. No one.”
I’ve never heard of The Media Line before today and I don’t know what they’re usually like, but I have to question the agenda of an outlet that would publish these embellishments. What the attackers actually did to civilians was bad enough for reasonable people to understand an IDF response to hurt the capabilities of the Gazan armed resistance and maybe try to extract some of the hostages. However, embellishing what happened serves the purposes of distracting from the IDFs failures and further dehumanize Palestinians in order to manufacturer consent for something more drastic and ghastly than measured retaliation against Hamas et al.
deleted by creator
Actually, it’s not embellished at all, in fact, if you’ve seen the archives, most reports under-sell the atrocities. You have to wonder why both The Media Line and The Guardian were at the same press conference, yet The Media Line chose to show the picture with the metal wire.
It’s because The Media Line clearly has an agenda to garner an emotional response from its audience?
That can certainly be true.
Another point of view is that sources like The Guardian are irresponsible for not showing the images when many people are accusing Israel of embellishment.
Yes there is a picture and there is a metal wire there and there are more, multitudes more.
There are trucks filled with burnt bodies, there’s images of a burnt child running and falling. There’s videos of smoke still rising from the bodies as first responders reach the scenes.
But you know, if you want more, here you go.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-67165128
https://www.haaretz.com/0000018b-3313-dff1-a5eb-ffffee6f0000
Now you have BBC who corroborates the metal wire, and Haaretz that describes the beheaded babies as accurate, both well known and trusted sources.
If you actually want the archive with the first responder telegram that corroborates all this too I can PM it also.
Removed by mod
Yay another excuse to kill more civvies.
The numbers are lower now though
Bunch of morons on both sides
I’m not sure I’d call Hamas morons honestly. Hamas, while committing war crimes against both Israelis and Palestinians, have formulated a situation that seems to have made a huge swath of people completely ignore that. They’re fighting an information war very successfully through effective disinformation campaigns.
Netanyahu and company are a bunch of morons though, which is why the Israelis want to boot them from office.
Removed by mod
Never said they did
