I know they roughly explained why, but it seems pretty insane they jumped the gun without having any of the users input and want people to go to another instance just for that community
I think it is very well explained. You don’t need to go to other instance to follow them.
They are just merging with another community for convenience.
I don’t get why are you so upset. It’s not a big deal.
Also, you can create your own community in any instance you want.
Send me a link please. I’m kinda slow learning lemmy.
“I don’t get why are you so upset. It’s not a big deal.”
first off I’m not? I’m just confused why the entire modteam just refused to get everyone’s input and did what they wanted anyway which is why people left reddit in the first place.
Second, it’s not convenient to just close a community without anyone’s knowledge and punish the users who don’t want to move so suddenly.
I get the feeling that you don’t understand that you don’t need to sign up at the other instance to subscribe to the community. You can just click the link and subscribe from your current account, and everything will be as it was.
Not if you’re on kbin. The new server isn’t federated with kbin.social for some reason.
There’s a reason why I don’t use kbin. Well, two. 1. Kbin federation sucks and is weird as fuck and keeps turning off and on, and 2. Where API, I script the shit out of everything, API pls. Apiiiiiii
They’re working on the API right now. Kbin is much newer than Lemmy. Lemmy’s been around for like 3 years while Kbin is a few months old.
I know :) I’m partially kidding. I tried kbin. The UI was too weird for me. That’s actually the main reason I didn’t use it. It felt less customizable. I had a hard time not seeing just the defaults. In fact I’m not sure in all this time I’ve subbed to anything from my kbin acc.
Man this defediverse stuff gets tiring
Is it defederated? If not, afaik, someone will have to search for it first (and then post/comment? I forget. Lol). It doesn’t federate automatically.
There’s almost 900 subscribers on kbin that cannot access lemdro.id at all.
kbin.social seems to be to blame for this, smaller instances work: https://fedia.io/m/android@lemdro.id/t/76197/META-The-merger-from-lemmy-world-has-locked-out-k-bin-members#comments
“I’m not upset, I’m just using the same words upset people use”
You don’t have to move your account. You can subscribe to the other community on the other instance from your existing account. That’s the beauty of the Fediverse.
Unless you’re on Kbin, which is not federated.
Your first point…I’m sorry, it just looks like a classic “strawman”. All I will say is that there are many reasons to leave reddit, but this particular argument fails on a simple premise: # most of the time, users upset with specific mods likely did not leave reddit, but rather just created new subreddits in direct competition. But there is no singular reason to leave reddit; even so, the most popular reason currently is something entirely different.
Second, the community explicitly was not closed; it was relocated. As others have pointed out already, this does not remove or restrict your access in any meaningful way.
Last but not least, there reasons are very clearly and directly communicated. I see no fault with their reasoning, or the action they took.
Part of the beauty of Lemmy is fracturing intentionally into smaller instances. The content is no less accessable to people who want it, and it’ll hopefully provide a better, more reliable experience by being off lemmy.world on a smaller instance.
I believe many are trying to help reduce the load in lemmy.world, where most new users (including myself) started.
I don’t really care either way, but this brings up questions of potential “cybersquatting”. The fediverse is supposed to allow for multiple communities in multiple instances. Let’s say i want to create a community about… basketweaving. Is it ok to create a /c/basketweaving community on all the top 20 instances, and then lock and redirect 19 of them to /c/basketweaving@lemmy.world?
Kinda just sounded like Lemdroid was a better fit for them. I’m already subscribed, the fediverse is awesome.
I can see why they did it. World is far too ubiquitous to be responsive. I have a harder time interacting with world than any other instance.
If you don’t like the way they run their community, you’re free to start your own or even your own instance, that’s the beauty of federation
It’s a good move. Having users and posts spread out over different communities isn’t good. Especially when it’s a niche community.
(There are three OpenTTD communities. None of them will be compelling when it’s all split up.)
I don’t agree with their decision but I understand their reasons. Probably the new instance is more suitable for the community, however they were growing in one of the biggest Lemmy instances. I think the best they could’ve done was to ask the community. Despite of that, I expect the android community to continue growing as it was before moving.
I can understand that instead of the others commenting, but I don’t really agree with the idea of them arbitrarily deciding they can do whatever they want with the community and punish the users who weren’t aware of that and don’t want to move and or check to another place.
Seems a bit barbaric and awkwardtheturtle esk imo to just do a bunch of stuff without asking the community if they’d like to switch, they just decided “no we’re going to close and you’re gonna like it” essentially lol
Maybe Lemmy isn’t for you.
deleted by creator
How is it punishing users? Literally all you need to do is click subscribe in the new community and nothing will be different.
“we’re keen to avoid unnecessary fragmentation for existing members and confusion for any newcomers.”
ah yes because locking the entire community without anyone’s knowledge and consent first isn’t totally insane and like a certain other platform we left from
They don’t owe you anything. Their reasons are very clear. Feel free to subscribe to the other channel.
It takes less than five seconds to unsub from the old community and sub to the new one. Job done.
You are here in bad faith. You’re not asking a question you just want to vent.
