You can already replace your own iPhone battery without any technical expertise. I hope the law is more specific than that, because there are many things OEMs can do to comply and still make it a giant pain in the ass to do.
I’ve replaced multiple iPhone batteries with only a YouTube video. The problem is that the glue and placement can be a complete pain in the ass and user replacement voids warranty. Hopefully the law specifically states that user replacement should have a certain level of ease and does not void warranty.
According to a draft version of the ecodesign regulation on the EU’s website, batteries should be replaceable “with no tool, a tool or set of tools that is supplied with the product or spare part, or basic tools.”
They provided a kit and step by step instructions. It remains to be seen how they handle it, but don’t be surprised if they argue they already comply if that’s how the language of the law is written.
You don’t seem to know it, but nebulous jargon like ‘technical expertise’ can be applied to anything like using a microwave so Apple includes instructions. Not seeing how this invalidates their point
Most people can’t put on a screen protector properly. I wouldn’t perhaps go as far as claiming replacing iPhone battery takes no technical expertise. It’s not hard but not quite easy either. In the case of iPhone there’s also that even if you do it properly the device still detects it’s not the original Apple approved battey so they limit functions on your phone such as battery health, true tone etc. New MacBooks does this aswell.
Technical expertise includes really basic things like being comfortable using a screwdriver on delicate equipment. Lots of people lack that level of expertise.
Yeah it’s baffling seeing the people on the internet thinking this is a big F you to apple especially. Have these people never watched any iPhone teardown videos? Replacing an iPhone battery is about as easy as it gets.
Having said that, Apple’s official iPhone battery replacement program means that I wouldn’t even bother doing it myself even though I’m capable of it, because apple do it cheaper than my time is worth while giving me a warranty.
It’s because you didn’t say fuck apple. Unfortunately on the internet to many people discussion on this either comes down to “yay apple” or “fuck apple”, and they up/down vote accordingly.
As you said, to anyone that has ever even thought about replacing a battery in an iPhone this will change nothing because replacing the battery in an iPhone is as easy as it can get short of having a removable back plate, and we know 100% that’s not coming back.
You can already replace your own iPhone battery without any technical expertise. I hope the law is more specific than that, because there are many things OEMs can do to comply and still make it a giant pain in the ass to do.
Press x to doubt. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
I’ve replaced multiple iPhone batteries with only a YouTube video. The problem is that the glue and placement can be a complete pain in the ass and user replacement voids warranty. Hopefully the law specifically states that user replacement should have a certain level of ease and does not void warranty.
I believe it says the battery has to be replaceable by the end-user without any kind of tools or heat.
Common screw drivers are ok, or they include the specialised screw driver in the package. Heat is a no go though, which makes me very happy.
Source
So if I understand this correctly:
Hex screws are pretty standard. I’m not a lawyer, but I’d imagine they would be acceptable.
That being said, I never understood the reason to have 5 different types of screws around. Can we just have one type for everything?
All of that sounds pretty shitty and unreasonable
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/21/23079058/apple-self-service-iphone-repair-kit-hands-on
And this is something we don’t want. Battery should be replaced with no special tools other than regular screwdriver or simillar.
You don’t seem to know it, but you’re arguing against your point that you “need no technical expertise”
They provided a kit and step by step instructions. It remains to be seen how they handle it, but don’t be surprised if they argue they already comply if that’s how the language of the law is written.
You don’t seem to know it, but nebulous jargon like ‘technical expertise’ can be applied to anything like using a microwave so Apple includes instructions. Not seeing how this invalidates their point
The tagline is literally “I’m starting to think Apple doesn’t want us to repair them”.
also having watched SnazzyLabs do this swap, it’s complicated and you’ll need to contact Apple to deal with code changes.
And I literally said in my comment that it’s a pain in the ass. That’s not the point, what “technical expertise” means is.
Can you, though? No, you can’t. Its really hard to get right and super easy to fuck up. Source: Me.
So is changing out any part on your car. It remains to be seen how this is applied.
Most people can’t put on a screen protector properly. I wouldn’t perhaps go as far as claiming replacing iPhone battery takes no technical expertise. It’s not hard but not quite easy either. In the case of iPhone there’s also that even if you do it properly the device still detects it’s not the original Apple approved battey so they limit functions on your phone such as battery health, true tone etc. New MacBooks does this aswell.
They probably need additional legislation to stop companies from locking down products when non own parts are used.
With my shaky hands and clumsiness? I’d kill my phone just by touching the innards.
Technical expertise includes really basic things like being comfortable using a screwdriver on delicate equipment. Lots of people lack that level of expertise.
Yeah it’s baffling seeing the people on the internet thinking this is a big F you to apple especially. Have these people never watched any iPhone teardown videos? Replacing an iPhone battery is about as easy as it gets.
Having said that, Apple’s official iPhone battery replacement program means that I wouldn’t even bother doing it myself even though I’m capable of it, because apple do it cheaper than my time is worth while giving me a warranty.
It’s more baffling to me how my initial comment is not supportive of apple in anyway, yet people are acting like I’m defending it.
It’s because you didn’t say fuck apple. Unfortunately on the internet to many people discussion on this either comes down to “yay apple” or “fuck apple”, and they up/down vote accordingly.
As you said, to anyone that has ever even thought about replacing a battery in an iPhone this will change nothing because replacing the battery in an iPhone is as easy as it can get short of having a removable back plate, and we know 100% that’s not coming back.