I don’t know about Arthur Smith. I know some people are defending him cuz he can design a good offense, but I think he’s got some personality flaws. And those flaws make him not use his best guys. Here’s a video on him and why he’s not a good fit personality-wise.
I think the biggest question actually is “can he consistently design a good offense” I don’t really have as big an issue with ball distribution as most people, but hate a lot of his route concepts. All the other “personality” stuff is small potatoes. I’d lean toward moving on from him this year, but it really feels like people are upset at the wrong things.