It’s been a little over 2 weeks since the poll was created, so here’s the end results. A decent number of people submitted responses, and the compiled list seems to reflect most players’ opinions of the game pretty well. The end results are as follows:

A Tier: Luke, Ken, Juri, Guile, Dee Jay, Cammy, JP
B Tier: Blanka, Marisa, Chun-Li, E Honda, Manon
C Tier: Ryu, Kimberly, Dhalsim, Jamie, Zangief, Lily

The full H2H voting chart can be viewed here.