This is a universe with faster than light travel and near infinite resources. There’s a homeless shelter in one of the major cities. I helped them out. Why the fuck is there a homeless shelter in a universe with FTL and near infinite resources?

I’m starting to think Fallout under Bethesda isn’t a satire and their writers are just incapable of imagining anything beyond capitalism.

  • KobaCumTribute [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    43
    ·
    1 year ago

    The issue is the incongruity and how it’s fundamentally irresponsible to write inherently bad things in an uncritical or positive way. It’s fine to have morally grey things, but they should be consistent: the problems need to be shown, the consequences need to be shown.

    For example with the UC one can’t just be like “so yeah it’s a military dictatorship that renders anyone who hasn’t done a term of service in the government as stateless, but uh they do social welfare and they’re super tolerant and nice and stuff” because that doesn’t make sense: it’s incongruous that a state oriented around brutal militarism and its war machine that demands people actively participate in its machine to attain basic rights is then going to be this paragon of religious and cultural tolerance with a social safety net for all its stateless residents; it needs brutality and rage and sadism or it would not be designed the way it is, it would not have the rulers it does, it would not allow the social problems that it has.

    That’s why I describe it as it either needs to be better or worse: it needs ideological compassion and a drive to improve things for the people even if it is materially unable to do so and it needs to lose the fascism to do this, or its villainy needs to be played straight and its tone should reflect its elitist and militarist nature with the consequences of what such a system wants and needs put front and center.

    • UlyssesT [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      26
      ·
      1 year ago

      so yeah it’s a military dictatorship that renders anyone who hasn’t done a term of service in the government as stateless

      Unexamined Starship Troopers brain has infested generations of consumers and those consumers are now writing stories. lenin-rage

      • marx_mentat [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        It’s just what the US will be once it goes into space and it’s borders become nebulous. It’s the smiling face of neoliberal fascism (in space edition). Poor people in the US already live in that world.

        There’s nothing wrong with any of the analysis here, and I agree with all of it, but I think they are more applicable to a directed narrative experience or a movie rather than a sandbox game that simulates the authors world and serves as a hub for a bunch of different isolated stories.

        It’s good analysis and very informative for games like Disco Elysium or Baldurs Gate 3, but maybe not as useful for sandbox games that don’t have a main plotline. Other sandbox games like GTA have similarly flavored settings.

        I was also originally very turned off by the lack of personality in the factions and how generic a lot of the things are in the universe, but it really is a universe and there are a ton of different stories that are built on top of it and I’m starting to recognize that the stories might actually benefit from having a canvas that more closely reflects our own world to build on top of.

        • GenderIsOpSec [she/her]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          22
          ·
          1 year ago

          some of my favourite threads to lurk in on the subreddit were the ones relating to vidya and their worldbuilding looked at through a marxist lense. it gives me easy examples to understand the theory and it’s just fun to see clever people talking about dumb shit comfy