• 0 Posts
  • 20 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 4th, 2024

help-circle



  • Yep, I fully agree. At the tail end of Sarek’s life we learn he loved Spock. He doesn’t tell or show Spock ever, which would qualify him as a terrible parent by human standards but he’s a Vulcan so maybe that’s not how he should be judged. What Sarek also doesn’t do is end his feud with Spock which I think is a perfectly good standard on which to judge a Vulcan parent. So while I love Sarek as a character he’s a bad dad.





  • Thought of a little bit more:

    In Best of Both Worlds 1 it’s kind of unclear what the Borg plans for Earth are, actually. The Borg collective says “Your archaic cultures are authority driven. To facilitate our introduction into your societies, it has been decided that a human voice will speak for us in all communications” when they decide to capture Picard. Locutus says “Your life as it has been is over. From this time forward, you will service us.” I don’t know if the Borg goal was assimilating everyone at that point (or if the writers themselves had decided). From those bits it sounds like they want the resources of Earth and a slave caste of humans. When Guinan is briefing the crew she says the Borg destroyed her world and scattered her people, but there’s no mention of assimilation.

    By Best of Both Worlds 2 assimilation is the pretty clear goal. Locutus says that “you will become one with the Borg. You will all become one with the Borg.” Maybe the process of assimilating Picard was so revolutionary that it took the collective a minute to figure out how great it could be and then it became their entire driving force.



  • It isn’t just about becoming more perfect themselves, the Borg are trying to help everyone they can achieve perfection by becoming Borg. Locutus and the queen both express surprise and confusion as to why humans aren’t just letting assimilation happen. Locutus says “why do you resist us; we only wish to improve quality of life.”

    This wasn’t always the case; in their first appearance the Borg only wanted technological material. Assimilating every person would have been very inefficient for that goal and in fact we see their methods were different in the pre-assimilate everyone days. The Borg are hinted at in The Neutral Zone (before the Borg were written, but clearly they were foreshadowing some big future adversary and the pattern fits even though the distance doesn’t) when Worf says “The outpost was not just destroyed, it’s as though some great force just scooped it off the face of the planet.” Nearly directly echoed in Q Who, first appearance of the Borg, when again Worf says “It is as though some great force just scooped all the machine elements off the face of the planet.” Q also makes some remarks about the Borg not being interested in the ship’s life forms, only the technology and what they can use and consume. At that time the more efficient hoovering up everything they need method was used.

    Clearly at some point Borg priorities changed for some reason. Maybe they consumed the technology for biological assimilation, decided to test it out, and the people they tested it on were radical altruists and that ethos got muddled in the Borg desire for unity. By Best of Both Worlds we see that the Borg have babies; it looked to me like they were implied to be born / grown from Borg but it’s possible those were already what would become maturation chambers by Voyager’s time. If they are Borg babies perhaps they have some kind of pro-natalist position too: if they can make life perfect then they have a duty to create life in order for life to experience perfection.






  • I actually think the episode itself is quite good. The framing of the episode, the part where the dinos left earth and ended up in the delta quadrant, is just awful and follows a long terrible tradition of Trek not even having a cursory understanding of evolution. But the storytelling is good. Learning about both the Voth and Voyager from the perspective of Voth scientists is good. Having them be much more advanced than Voyager and then actually showing that is a nice change of pace. The moralizing part is good too: respecting the journey for scientific truth even is important, though the message is a little muddled because the science of the episode is so hilariously wrong. A Chakotay heavy plot without any sky spirits is nice. The Voth were relatively good looking aliens for the time.

    I think if it were rewritten just a little bit it’d be a top 10 Voyager episode.




  • I quite like StarSector too. It clearly owes a lot to the Escape Velocity series which I love.

    StarSector’s focus on colony management is super fun though. The recent patch was also quite good and seemed to add more story elements which I appreciate. I appreciate the unique looking ships even though some of them end up looking very ugly.

    I love working with the AIs. Smuggling them, integrating them into colonies, doing other spoilery things with them. I wish there were deeper mechanics there and more story too, but that could still happen.



  • Azathoth@kbin.runto196@lemmy.blahaj.zonepizza rules
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    23
    ·
    4 months ago

    Fairly sure that part is from Schisms where Riker and other crew members are being abducted while they sleep by aliens. At this point he knows he’s going to be abducted and has taken some stimulants to stay awake so he decided to get abducted in his uniform rather than his sleeping clothes.