• 0 Posts
  • 4 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 26th, 2023

help-circle


  • None of the major ISPs offer SLAs (service level agreements) with throughput guarantees for residential service. You’ll hear anecdotes from people here about their performance, but this is specific to their market and their specific network segment. You can’t make the leap from those anecdotes to “service type X is better” because it’s not the service type that’s delivering more throughput; it’s the ISP network design.

    Here’s the thing. All residential internet works over shared medium networks. The wire or fiber that goes back to the distribution node is shared amongst your neighbors. For fiber, it’s called a PON (passive optical network). For cable it’s called DOCSIS (please don’t at me if you’re an engineer, I’m generalizing). These networks use a shared physical layer to supply data to the last mile.

    So your actual throughput is usually limited by two factors:

    1. Traffic on your local loop / PON.
    2. Provisioning limitations at the distribution node.

    ISPs routinely oversell the throughput available on these networks. It’s how they turn a profit. Getting good speeds is a matter of finding the provider with the least over-provisioned network in your area. That last part is important. An ISP can be good in one region and lackluster in another.

    All that said, fiber networks tend to be newer, so it takes time for ISPs to sell them out. For example, if the cable provider in your area had a near monopoly, then the local phone provider rolled out fiber, it’s going to take time for people to switch. You can take advantage of that by adopting early. Just understand that your network performance will degrade as more people switch and you end up with more network contention.


  • Connecting switches is easy. You don’t really need to know anything. The main thing you need to avoid is accidentally creating a loop. I know that sounds dumb, but you’d be amazed how often it happens.

    How you connect this all up will depend on what you want to achieve. For example, if you want to supply 10 Gbe to all ports in your home, your plan may be different than if you want to supply 10 Gbe to your office, but stick to vanilla gigabit elsewhere.

    Hardware wise, you haven’t listed anything that requires a managed switch. That Juniper switch has some 10 Gbe capability, but it’s a managed switch that is way more complicated than you need. Plus you’d have to buy SFP to 10GBase-T adapters. That could set you back a couple hundred dollars.

    IMO, your best value is going to be something like the Netgear XS508M, 8-port, 10 Gb, unmanaged switch (currently $450 on Amazon). There is also a 5-port version, but it’s not much cheaper. Unfortunately, that means you won’t be able to provide 10 Gb to all 12 ports in your home. You’ll need one port to connect to the ATT modem/router and one to tie in your gigabit network.

    In the garage, you’ll put one Netgear 10G switch connected like this:

    [ATT]==[Netgear 10G]==[TP Link 1G]

    You can connect your patch panel based on your needs. For example, the upstairs office will go to the Netgear 10G switch, while the other ports can go to the TP Link.

    Upstairs in your office, you’ll need another Netgear 10G switch. You’ll plug all the devices in that room directly into the switch, then plug the switch into the wall to uplink to the Netgear 10G downstairs.

    Since your existing cabling is Cat6, you should be able to hit 5 Gbps without much trouble. 10 Gbps requires really good terminations. In fact, terminations are going to be your primary issue across the board. Gigabit is pretty forgiving. 10 Gbps is not forgiving at all.