You might not like him or disagree with him but if he was a nobody you wouldn’t have an opinion on him.
I dont think you know who you’re dealing with
The government should not be the arbiter of truth. Do you trust the FBI? Do you trust the CIA? You think they are the good guys? The dozens of coups all across the world? The endless spying and surveillance?
You’re advocating that these people should have even more power over you.
Do you also let cockroaches and rats run wild out in the open in your home?
To avoid cockroaches, you stop leaving food and water in the open. Turning the lights off and scurrying them away won’t help the issue.
We need to solve the economic issues to get rid of Nazis. Anything else is just turning the lights off. As long as people are struggling to pay bills and have a sense of instability and fear for the future… we’re going to have fascists. It doesn’t matter if you make it so they can’t speak in public. They will just speak in private and continue to grow.
We need broad ranging economic reforms.
You just described everything that happened by letting them have free speech
Give me specific examples. I don’t follow what you mean.
Nazis believe in the genocide of a racial group. Genocide is not normalized in the USA. It was not normalized by the Telecommunications Act.
Can we stop saying crazy things that didn’t happen?
Christianity has nothing to do with fascism. It can be used by fascists, sure. But if you look at Nazi Germany for example Hitler hated the church and there’s speculation he had plans to totally destroy it. Fascists don’t like groups of power that aren’t controlled by them. So for example the Catholic Church had to go. He tried to create a Protestant church called the “Reich Church” that was sort of a state religion but once that failed he gave up and suppressed the religious movements.
Have you ever actually dealt with cockroaches? They survive nuclear blasts. You need to remove the source of food and water otherwise all the traps in the world don’t make a difference. You leave one or two alive and they will just repopulate.
Plus consider the implications of what you’re saying. Let’s say we arrest and imprison every single Nazi. What’s going to happen? The ones that remain are going to stay real quiet, aren’t they? What then? Is the government going to be actively spying on every single communications in the country to try and find them?
That’s what it’ll take. And maybe it’ll even be possible. But consider what you have created. A massive surveillance state with broad ranging legal powers to detain and imprison “enemies of the state”. What happens when a far-right party gets elected? Remember, we are a democracy. What happens when the next Trump gets elected and says BLM are fascists?
Actually, we don’t need to imagine. If you look at his recent interview with Tucker Carlson that’s exactly what he said. He said the fascists are out to get him.
You don’t see any potential issues with this? None at all?
Honestly, we’re screwed. Unfortunately I think your wish will ultimately become reality and we will live in a brutal authoritarian surveillance state. I’m just glad I got to grow up before it became that way.
And you’re actually using Tucker Carlson as your example?..do you not understand that calling everyone else who obviously isnt fascist is a classic fascist tactic?
Yes. That is exactly what I’m trying to say. Let’s say a fascist comes to power. They call everyone else fascists.
Now they use the rules you just created to shut down speech that isn’t fascist.
You keep ignoring this or failing to understand. Prompting me to believe you are likely a bot.
I don’t think you really know anything about Chomsky’s corpus of work. I believe this because you didn’t mention any of his critiques of US imperialism or the propaganda model he outlined in his most famous book - Manufacturing Consent.
You speak confidently about things you don’t really understand. I’m going to stop engaging unless you start addressing the things I’m saying. I’m starting to think you might be a ChatGPT bot. Or maybe just a teenager, I don’t know.
That would be more concerning, to be honest. It’s understandable why a teenager hasn’t developed an adult’s perspective or a competent reading comprehension.
deleted by creator
You might not like him or disagree with him but if he was a nobody you wouldn’t have an opinion on him.
The government should not be the arbiter of truth. Do you trust the FBI? Do you trust the CIA? You think they are the good guys? The dozens of coups all across the world? The endless spying and surveillance?
You’re advocating that these people should have even more power over you.
To avoid cockroaches, you stop leaving food and water in the open. Turning the lights off and scurrying them away won’t help the issue.
We need to solve the economic issues to get rid of Nazis. Anything else is just turning the lights off. As long as people are struggling to pay bills and have a sense of instability and fear for the future… we’re going to have fascists. It doesn’t matter if you make it so they can’t speak in public. They will just speak in private and continue to grow.
We need broad ranging economic reforms.
Give me specific examples. I don’t follow what you mean.
deleted by creator
Nazis believe in the genocide of a racial group. Genocide is not normalized in the USA. It was not normalized by the Telecommunications Act.
Can we stop saying crazy things that didn’t happen?
Christianity has nothing to do with fascism. It can be used by fascists, sure. But if you look at Nazi Germany for example Hitler hated the church and there’s speculation he had plans to totally destroy it. Fascists don’t like groups of power that aren’t controlled by them. So for example the Catholic Church had to go. He tried to create a Protestant church called the “Reich Church” that was sort of a state religion but once that failed he gave up and suppressed the religious movements.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Have you ever actually dealt with cockroaches? They survive nuclear blasts. You need to remove the source of food and water otherwise all the traps in the world don’t make a difference. You leave one or two alive and they will just repopulate.
Plus consider the implications of what you’re saying. Let’s say we arrest and imprison every single Nazi. What’s going to happen? The ones that remain are going to stay real quiet, aren’t they? What then? Is the government going to be actively spying on every single communications in the country to try and find them?
That’s what it’ll take. And maybe it’ll even be possible. But consider what you have created. A massive surveillance state with broad ranging legal powers to detain and imprison “enemies of the state”. What happens when a far-right party gets elected? Remember, we are a democracy. What happens when the next Trump gets elected and says BLM are fascists?
Actually, we don’t need to imagine. If you look at his recent interview with Tucker Carlson that’s exactly what he said. He said the fascists are out to get him.
You don’t see any potential issues with this? None at all?
Honestly, we’re screwed. Unfortunately I think your wish will ultimately become reality and we will live in a brutal authoritarian surveillance state. I’m just glad I got to grow up before it became that way.
deleted by creator
Yes. That is exactly what I’m trying to say. Let’s say a fascist comes to power. They call everyone else fascists.
Now they use the rules you just created to shut down speech that isn’t fascist.
You keep ignoring this or failing to understand. Prompting me to believe you are likely a bot.
deleted by creator
Ok, so you would put half of the GOP in prison? Good luck with that. I also want a million bucks and a harem of curly hair dark girls.
It’s only a matter of time before the GOP wins another presidency. It’s probably going to happen next year.
What then? Do you trust Trump with the ability to define what is and isn’t valid speech?
^^ please answer this don’t ignore it for the 4th time
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
I don’t think you really know anything about Chomsky’s corpus of work. I believe this because you didn’t mention any of his critiques of US imperialism or the propaganda model he outlined in his most famous book - Manufacturing Consent.
You speak confidently about things you don’t really understand. I’m going to stop engaging unless you start addressing the things I’m saying. I’m starting to think you might be a ChatGPT bot. Or maybe just a teenager, I don’t know.
deleted by creator
This isn’t a debate. I guess you aren’t a bot and are just a teenager after all.
deleted by creator
That would be more concerning, to be honest. It’s understandable why a teenager hasn’t developed an adult’s perspective or a competent reading comprehension.
deleted by creator
Something I learned about the Rwandan genocides in 1994 is that comparing humans to insects is one of the first steps of genocidal ideology.
deleted by creator
Why do you think I’m arguing with you?
deleted by creator
Yeah, I wasn’t taking issue. I was providing information.