Mouse embryos have been grown on the International Space Station and developed normally in the first study indicating it could be possible for humans to reproduce in space, a group of Japanese scientists said.
rather than let at least some be born in order to study those, too?
They only had fertilised embryos. They couldn’t let them develop any further as they would have to implanted into a host mother to continue to develop.
This is a first step to test if initial cell division after fertilisation works as expected in micro-gravity.
I just seems inefficient considering that not only would they have to do that as a logical next step in the study and the cost of launching mice embryos would
The skills required for micro-surgery in micro gravity probably do not exist yet. It is not the cost of sending a few mouse embronic cells that held them back but this.
from a cost-benefit analysis of how to best spend grant money
When it comes to grant money:
“Prove the embryo develops normally before we spend the money trying to implant them.” Would be the normal process.
Ok, but the cost of launching all that into space has got to be the vast majority of the cost of money and time (by an incredible and unsustainable amount), so wouldn’t it make sense to somehow streamline that?
Certainly there must be a way to do that without compromising the integrity of the science and data.
but the cost of launching all that into space has got to be the vast majority of the cost of money and time
The cost of what, a few grams of embryos? The marginal cost is basically zero as there are regular resupply flights to the ISS that are already bought and paid for. The frozen embryos would ride up with them.
The real cost is the cost of sending up the mission specialist to run the experiment and as I said the person who ran this experiment is not the person you need to run the experiment you are talking about.
First experiment: This is a pretty simple one, place frozen samples in machine bring them up to temp, let develop for four days, refreeze and send back to earth. Some for analysis and other to implant into a host mother, grow to term on earth and see if early microgravity had any effect on development.
If this shows good results. Move on to the next step.
Possible next experiment: Send pregnant mouse to station, and return once the babies are born. Test for issues.
They only had fertilised embryos. They couldn’t let them develop any further as they would have to implanted into a host mother to continue to develop.
This is a first step to test if initial cell division after fertilisation works as expected in micro-gravity.
The skills required for micro-surgery in micro gravity probably do not exist yet. It is not the cost of sending a few mouse embronic cells that held them back but this.
When it comes to grant money:
“Prove the embryo develops normally before we spend the money trying to implant them.” Would be the normal process.
Ok, but the cost of launching all that into space has got to be the vast majority of the cost of money and time (by an incredible and unsustainable amount), so wouldn’t it make sense to somehow streamline that?
Certainly there must be a way to do that without compromising the integrity of the science and data.
The cost of what, a few grams of embryos? The marginal cost is basically zero as there are regular resupply flights to the ISS that are already bought and paid for. The frozen embryos would ride up with them.
The real cost is the cost of sending up the mission specialist to run the experiment and as I said the person who ran this experiment is not the person you need to run the experiment you are talking about.
First experiment: This is a pretty simple one, place frozen samples in machine bring them up to temp, let develop for four days, refreeze and send back to earth. Some for analysis and other to implant into a host mother, grow to term on earth and see if early microgravity had any effect on development.
If this shows good results. Move on to the next step.
Possible next experiment: Send pregnant mouse to station, and return once the babies are born. Test for issues.