Can’t you / shouldn’t you be wearing a rain coat or outer shell if you think you might get wet?
I get there are some situations where its impossible to keep underlayers dry, like if your on a boat or Backcountry camping, but for the majority of people and situations some layers of cotton or synthetic under a shell should be fine.
Rule #1 of cold weather survival: You sweat, you die.
Wool isn’t going to save you. Taking off layers will. If it’s raining, wool won’t protect you any more than cotton will because neither are water-resistant. Lol.
So sad this needs to be spelled out for ya’ll, but the voting snowball effect has already taken hold.
Now we have like 10+ who legitimately believe wool will save you in a cold, wet environment where cotton wouldn’t.
wool fibers are able to accumulate the moisture (from sweat or small rain) fully in the central part (cortex) and simultaneously keep the hydrophobic surface shelves dry, thus offering relative high thermal resistance and dry (warm) contact feeling even with 30–40% moisture in the fabrics
thermal comfort properties of wool fibers and wool fabrics cannot be found in cotton and viscose fabrics, (Oglakcioglu and Marmarali 2010) where the deterioration of their thermal comfort properties with the increasing relative moisture is much stronger and quicker than in the studied woolen fabrics samples. Thus, even in case of wool and wool/PES fabrics subject to some antifelting treatment, like in our case, the thermal comfort properties of the investigated samples exhibited relatively slow decrease of their thermal resistance and relatively slow increase of their thermal contact feeling, when the relative moisture content increases. That is why the woolen fabrics belong to the most comfortable and valuable commercial textile products.
If you’re outside in cold weather, yes, you should wear a shell layer. However, it’s not just water coming in from the outside, it’s sweat from your body. You can’t avoid sweating; it’s how your body regulates temperature. But compare, say, a polypropylene sports jersey to a cotton t-shirt on a hot day; the cotton gets wet with sweat, and then stays wet longer. In really cold weather, that’s bad. (And if you’ve ever gone snowshoeing, you know that you’ll work up a sweat fast.)
There’s a lot of contradictory-seeming things happening, but it’s pretty easy to test results for yourself. Get comparable long underwear in both cotton and Merino wool, comparative outer garments in wool v. cotton (say, German or Swiss wool milsurp field pants and shirt v. heavy cotton duck pants and heavy cotton flannel shirt), go outside on a cold winter day and do the same activities wearing different fibers, and see which ends up feeling warmer.
“Warmer than cotton” is not the same as “warm” lol. That’s what I’m trying to get through the people who think that if it’s cold and wet enough cotton can’t protect you when wool can.
Can’t you / shouldn’t you be wearing a rain coat or outer shell if you think you might get wet?
I get there are some situations where its impossible to keep underlayers dry, like if your on a boat or Backcountry camping, but for the majority of people and situations some layers of cotton or synthetic under a shell should be fine.
If you over exert yourself and sweat cotton underlayers are useless.
Rule #1 of cold weather survival: You sweat, you die.
Wool isn’t going to save you. Taking off layers will. If it’s raining, wool won’t protect you any more than cotton will because neither are water-resistant. Lol.
So sad this needs to be spelled out for ya’ll, but the voting snowball effect has already taken hold.
Now we have like 10+ who legitimately believe wool will save you in a cold, wet environment where cotton wouldn’t.
Laughable.
Hey look, someone studied it!
It’s totally possible that I’m too dumb to understand a scientific paper, but it sure looks like you’re a dumbass.
So… can you quote anything from it that proves your point? Or do you just link to studies and have other people read them for you?
Lol.
Sure, lazy ass.
Idk able the whole die thing but I know what I’d rather be wearing
perspiration. Sweat will sap heat just as fast as water if you’re wearing cotton
If you’re outside in cold weather, yes, you should wear a shell layer. However, it’s not just water coming in from the outside, it’s sweat from your body. You can’t avoid sweating; it’s how your body regulates temperature. But compare, say, a polypropylene sports jersey to a cotton t-shirt on a hot day; the cotton gets wet with sweat, and then stays wet longer. In really cold weather, that’s bad. (And if you’ve ever gone snowshoeing, you know that you’ll work up a sweat fast.)
There’s a lot of contradictory-seeming things happening, but it’s pretty easy to test results for yourself. Get comparable long underwear in both cotton and Merino wool, comparative outer garments in wool v. cotton (say, German or Swiss wool milsurp field pants and shirt v. heavy cotton duck pants and heavy cotton flannel shirt), go outside on a cold winter day and do the same activities wearing different fibers, and see which ends up feeling warmer.
Yes, you should.
The idea that wool will “keep you warm when it’s wet and cold” is such a crock of shit I’m surprised it’s getting upvoted like it does.
Wool will keep you warmer than cotton when it’s wet and cold. As usual, shades of grey get lost in the discussion.
“Warmer than cotton” is not the same as “warm” lol. That’s what I’m trying to get through the people who think that if it’s cold and wet enough cotton can’t protect you when wool can.
That’s just malarkey.