When someone sends a message to another WhatsApp user, their device creates a different session key for each device the receiver is using, thus telling the sender how many devices the receiver is using.
So like any other service using the Signal protocol, or am I wrong?
I knew my brother got a new phone because signal told me their usual device had changed.
What are some good reasons for this? My initial thought is that it’s intrusive and violates a user’s privacy.
Well, I knew my brother was getting a new phone soon anyways so getting notified his device changed wasn’t a surprise. Otherwise, getting notified hia device changed without that knowledge may have triggered me to contact him elsewhere to ask if he did. Signal is mostly going to be conversations between close/trusted individuals. It doesn’t tell you what they changed to, the message basically tells you that if this person didn’t legitimately change devices then it might be a bad actor.
Oh, so it’s not like “person is on their computer” or “person is on their iPhone”? That’s what I was imagining and that can obviously be problematic, since some devices would be location bound, and you might not want someone to know your location. Also if it identifies your device, then it’s another avenue for bullying (apparently kids get bullied for not having iPhones) and some potential security risks.
That seems more like a feature.
Imagine that you haven’t seen your brother in some time and then you start getting phishing messages.
I’ve got no issue with it. I’m just relating what they said to my experience.
In other news, water is wet. I only see FUD here.
Water is actually not wet. It only makes other materials/objects wet. Wetness is the ability of a liquid to adhere to the surface of a solid. So if you say something is wet we mean the liquid is sticking to the surface of the object
Where is the good old water is not wet bot from reddit times when we need him.
Be the change you want to see!
Sadly the people here dont seem to know this copy pasta. I got downvotes.
You forgot either quotes around the whole thing, a reference, or “/s”
Thats not how copy pastas work
Yes, but what about wet ice?
That’s wet Water as well.
Yes true. Ice is an non liquid object. So if you have a thin layer of still liquid water on the ice then the Ice is wet.
Water sticks to itself, that’s why we have surface tension, so I’d say water is indeed wet.
This is the best summary I could come up with:
Tal Be’ery, the co-founder and CTO of crypto wallet maker ZenGo, found that it’s possible to determine whether a user on WhatsApp is using more than just the mobile app.
Be’ery demonstrated and proved his findings in tests performed with WhatsApp numbers controlled by TechCrunch.
“[It] could be useful for information gathering and plotting an attack,” Runa Sandvik, a digital security expert, told TechCrunch, referring to how hackers could figure out that their target is using WhatsApp on a desktop, which is generally an easier target to compromise than a mobile phone.
“It at least tells you more about the devices they use and how ‘accessible’ their WhatsApp setup may be,” said Sandivk, who is the founder of Granitt, a startup that aims to train at-risk people like journalists, activists, and politicians.
Meta’s spokesperson Zade Alsawah told TechCrunch that the company received Be’ery’s research and concluded that the app’s current design “is what users want and expect.”
Anyone can find out this kind of information by using WhatsApp on the web and inspecting traffic with a browser’s developer tool, Be’ery explained.
The original article contains 533 words, the summary contains 181 words. Saved 66%. I’m a bot and I’m open source!
Jokes on you, I don’t
And…?
It means you have even less privacy than the already abysmal notion that you thought you had.
Or,
That Whatsapp users are an even bigger set of Meta’s removed. 'Cause they are just raping yet another previously unknown data point.
This isn’t new, interesting or noval information. If you run whats app from the desktop app or from web.WhatsApp.com on you’re browser on a PC then no shit they know your on your PC
Why does it matter if the people I’m chatting with know if in onnmy PC?
I see the issue. The issue is that you seemingly did not bother to read the link. Since that is not what is being discussed. It is not that you cannot tell whether someone is using a PC or a phone, but rather which PC or phone or peripheral you are using if you have number of them. Your point has literally nothing to do with the post.
“Be’ery wrote in his blog post explaining the data leak that it is a consequence of the way WhatsApp is designed: When someone sends a message to another WhatsApp user, their device creates a different session key for each device the receiver is using, thus telling the sender how many devices the receiver is using.”
This is a security feature to let you know that the sender may be an imposter, right? Like matrix’s verified sessions, if my friend gets a new phone or pc it’s unverified and I have to verify the new session through another means, like in person or phone.
