- cross-posted to:
- foss@lemmy.eco.br
- cross-posted to:
- foss@lemmy.eco.br
You must log in or register to comment.
I just learned about it yesterday. Seems like Vivaldi but on gecko, which I always wanted to see.
Unfortunately it seems like it’s maintained by only one overworked dev. It needs more funding and more devs.AFAIK it’s maintained by a group called Ablaze and I think I saw them mention they are university students and opensource enthusiasts in Github discussions.
There are blog posts on their site about changes to their team and leadership. Their blog is in Japanese but I just translate it with Firefox’s inbuilt translator. So I don’t think it’s a single dev.
Oh my bad then. That was just the impression I got based on posts in floorp subreddit.
Midori seems pretty shady. I remember it as a super minimalistic browser, but now it seems like they are straight up taking someone elses work and just changing the name and sponsor links within. I tried it and it seems like 1:1 copy of floorp.
What I said, anyway try also Otter, even if it isn’t a Gecko browser (AFAIK it also admits in last versions the import of Chrome extensions (Qt5 is a fork of Blink), also userscripts without the need of Tamper, Greay or Violentmonkey). It will be also the fastest browser you ever have tested.
I did try Otter in the past when I was looking for the Opera replacement, never really liked it. It seems like it’s pretty dead…last update was 2 years ago. And speed was never really my priority for the browser anyways. I’m not really looking to replace my browser, I’m happy with Vivaldi, I just like to check what else is there. I was happy to see that there is a browser based on gecko that seems to be going in the similar direction as Vivaldi.
No, only some parts are not updated some years, but the last core update is from 10 hours ago, others from a month. It’s a very small community and logical that the developement isn’t so active as in the big ones. The last updates also includes the possibility to use extensions, before not prossible. But yes, it’s always better to use browsers in active developement and community. Which isn’t the case in indie and marginal browsers and forks, mostly 1-2 devs projects.
So it has tab stacking? (I don’t treestyle/vertical tabs, it’s not the same thing)
I only took a glance, but I didn’t notice that feature unfortunately.
I googled just now and it might be in dev, fingers crossed
You mean multi tab ?
I mean tab stacking
Seems like a good browser. The only issue is how maintained will it be. Also, librewolf has been released and maintained properly and is proven time and time again. Not sure how different it is from LW.
There’s a hype around floorp right now. Certainly because it’s new and it offers a high level of aesthetic customization.
Unfortunately it doesn’t work for me because:
-
it takes up too much RAM compared to others. Even though people don’t really care about that on modern machine it goes against my philosophy.
-
I’ve been tweaking Firefox for a long time to get the highest privacy possible but it was extremely painful and I don’t want to redo that with floorp.
-
my system look is extremely minimalist and I remove any visual effects in apps I use which would go against the point of floorp.
These are some reasons why I went with librewolf since it was released in 2020. It’s efficient, well maintained, kept up to date with the latest Firefox version, and most importantly to me: deeply respectful of your privacy. Their privacy approach is very well explained in the FAQ It passed all the EFF tests better than any browser I’ve tested after hours of tweaks.
This is only my personal experience and preference. Per the Floorp developer himself privacy is not given the utmost care and users should prefer librewolf in that regard. If you want to use normal privacy and excellent Firefox derivatives, with no doubts, floorp will fit your needs.
highest privacy possible but it was extremely painful and I don’t want to redo that with floorp.
Uhm… policies or user.js? Look at arkenfox, create an override, use their updater. Dont do about:config changes on your own. You can just copy-paste that user.js into the floorp profile.
Policies are also nice, mozilla has good documentation.
Floorp being based off ESR is the downside of all the fancy GUI tweaks, just like with Thunderbird. Would not want to use that. Like, JXL is already working in regular Firefox with the right build arguments
Yep, I’ve been through the user.js path and librewolf is also using it so I don’t have to do it manually anymore. But there’s more tweaks than that to reach a high level of privacy and I couldn’t pass it until I found librewolf who integrates them.
I’m fine with librewolf policies and I like their general philosophy as well which is important to me as well when chosing an app.Yes, Librewolf is basically Arkenfox. I made a project fixing Arkenfox for me.
https://github.com/trytomakeyouprivate/Arkenfox-softening
It is probably not that well maintained and the general arkenfox stuff is not easy to deal with it, very overcomplex.
But basically you want to keep track of the updates but still override the things you like.
So arkenfox sucks in many ways, it is extremely “I hate mozilla” opinionated to a level where version update “whats new” dialogs are completely impossible. I would highly prefer a compartimentalized set of settings, but maintenance is hard.
Have you seen the mercury fork? it looks more aligned to your philosophy. I’ve tried it, and it seems very interesting. I’m not using it just because they’re often a few versions behind mainline, but it’s on my watchlist.
Thanks for sharing. I’ve not been sold by the info on their website. Too many details are missing. At a glance, privacy concerns seem better addressed by librewolf. Also there have been some issues in update history cycles and some reviews (which I won’t cite here with respect to project) didn’t help in building confidence.
-
I really like it too, it feels very fast compared to normal Firefox
Yep, I agree with you. It’s very fast compared to normal firefox on my pc.
“Safari feels snappier”
I’m talking about desktop experience, but sure…?
Why?
I see the web site, but the features listed are common to many other forks. What makes Floorp better than, say, Mull?
Floorp is available on desktop, while Mull is mostly Android
“Mostly?” It’s a desktop program available in the Arch repos. Why is it “mostly?”
Omg no. That is “Mullvad Browser” which is a version of Torbrowser with a preinstalled extension and no Tor. Basically an ad project for MullvadVPN, because Librewolf already exists.
Mull is Firefox Mobile + Arkenfox user.js, made by DivestOS developers.
Mullvad is distributed and funded by Mullvad VPN but it was made entirely by the folks at Tor project. It’s by no means “just an ad for a VPN”. It’s the best anti-fingerprinting browser you can use to browse without connecting to the Tor network. Anti-fingerprinting is very hard hard business. There are a lot of academic research around it that needs perfect implementation. You can tell how much we need that from Google blocking 3rd party cookies in Chrome. It means they figured out a way to track users reliably without the use of cookies and they want to drawn out the competition.
Yes for sure, Mullvad Browser is fine. It is Torbrowser without Tor, I think that makes no sense so I would just use Librewolf with Mullvad VPN systemwide
Huh. TIL.
I use mull on my phone but I can’t find it in arch, that would be nice. Do you have a link?
Idk if the ui would be all that nice but you could try a waydroid setup, its pretty seamless
It’s in AUR. There’s also a
-binversion.Oh you mean mullvad! They’re two different apps.
Yah, someone pointed out my mistake. Ah, well.
If you wanna go for privacy then Mullvad , Tor or Librewolf. But For customization and stuff floorp is good.
It’s an interesting attempt to replicate Vivaldi’s functionality in a Firefox fork. Unfortunately it retains the horrible printing experience of Firefox.
Printing like to dead trees?
You could just use the system print dialog instead of Firefox’s if that works better for you, I think it’s possible to set it as default.
Just read a policy for that, or user.js, or about:config
Yeah I tried that. On KDE Neon there’s no instant preview of what’s getting printed in the system print dialog. Which means even more dead trees get wasted. Printing is a functionality that Mozilla has decided is unimportant so it’s unlikely to ever improve.
