I myself am really on the fence about this.

I hate what Reddit has done, as I was removed as a moderator on my sub. But I much prefer the UI to Lemmy so far. I’m also having a hard time understanding how this all works. I was familiar with Reddit, and it is obviously a way more active community.

But I also used Apollo and hate how they’ve done him so dirty.

Will you guys return if Reddit rights it’s wrongs?

  • xargs@lemmy.worldEnglish
    3·
    1 year ago

    This is the most degen reason to give, but the likelihood is I would go back. Lemmy is solid though there’s a couple of things that make me wonder if it’s worth fully commiting.

    a) Userbase. If reddit went back, subreddits would likely reopen, change their rules back to how they were before, and therefore the numbers would follow.

    b) Centralised. I know this one will piss people off, but the fragmentation of lemmy is a bit too much. I have the option to put all my trust into a single account on one instance and subscribe fedarated if instances support it, or I can create 20 different accounts across different instances.

    c) Retention of userstats. While I’ve not got rediculous amounts of karma like some people do, I have a a little bit, and rebuilding that is a bit ass.

      • TechnoBabble@lemmy.worldEnglish
        4·
        1 year ago

        Isn’t karma just like an anti-spam mechanism that barely works?

        And you get karma just by posting whatever the community wants to hear. So it’s not like it shows how enlightened you are or anything.

        Anyway, one thing that bothered me about Reddit’s karma system, is that people would delete their comments if they got a few downvotes, even if they had something important to say.

        Here on Lemmy, you can quickly see both upvotes and downvotes. So if someone says something controversial due to politics or whatever, they’re less likely to delete their comment because they can see “ahh, I’m not just being mercilessly attacked, 50 people upvoted me.”

        That can be abused I guess, but I like that it promotes discussion that isn’t just echo-chamber nonsense. We’ll just have to see how it works in practice.